Lesson Shuffle: Shuffle, Pick, Grow
Collaboration & DiscussionCard G4

Every Hand Up

Nobody sits this one out

OngoingOne-time setupModerate

The move

Give everyone think time, then pull a name stick at random so anyone could be asked.

See how it works

Askno handsThinkeveryone, 5–10 sPull a stickrandomSupportphone a friendStick backanyone, any timeAnyone couldbe next

At a glance

Time in class
Ongoing; seconds per question
Prep
One-time: write each student’s name on a craft stick (10 minutes), or use a random name picker.
Materials
Craft sticks and a cup
Grouping
Whole class
Use it when
Any time you ask the class a question

Why it works

When only volunteers answer, the same few students do the thinking. If anyone might be called, everyone prepares an answer. In one study, regular cold-calling increased how often students volunteered and made them more comfortable speaking.

Step by step

In class: about 17 seconds

  1. 2Ask the question5 seconds
  2. 3Think time5–10 seconds
  3. 4Pull a stick2 seconds

Before class: Set the norm

  1. Set the normOnce“In here, everyone thinks. I’ll pull names at random, and you can always phone a friend.”
  2. Ask the question5 secondsNo hands.
  3. Think time5–10 seconds“Think. Everyone have an answer ready.”
  4. Pull a stick2 secondsRead the name.
  5. SupportAs neededIf they’re stuck: “Want to phone a friend, or hear it again?” Come back to them after.
  6. Return the stickPut it back so anyone can be called again.

See it in action

“What sound does ‘ph’ make?”

Watch out for

Level up

Make it work for everyone

Tech option

Any random name picker on the board works the same way.

Resources

Pairs well with

Triple Play: Dialogue and Accountability. This card works well with Circle Up Check and Think Pair Rotate Share. What’s a Triple Play?

Reflect

Did you hear from students you don’t usually hear from?

Evidence

Moderate

Dallimore, E. J., Hertenstein, J. H., & Platt, M. B. (2013). Impact of cold-calling on student voluntary participation. Journal of Management Education, 37(3), 305–341. Cold-calling increased voluntary participation and reduced discomfort (college students).

Wiliam, D. (2011). Embedded Formative Assessment. Solution Tree Press. Recommends random selection with think time so every student prepares an answer.

Find the research: Dallimore (2013) · Wiliam (2011)