The move
Students use today’s concept to propose a fix for a real problem nearby.
See how it works
- Real problemLocal and small
- Today’s conceptName the idea you used
- ProposalProblem, concept, fix
- Pitch1 minute per group
At a glance
- Time in class
- 10–20 minutes
- Prep
- 5 minutes: pick one real problem from your school or town that today’s concept can help with.
- Materials
- None (paper for notes)
- Grouping
- Groups of 3–4
- Use it when
- After students learn a concept and before they practice it
Why it works
Using an idea on a real problem shows students why it matters and gives them a reason to understand it well enough to apply it. Tasks that mirror real-world use build knowledge that transfers beyond the worksheet.
Step by step
In class: about 10–14 min
- 1Pose the problem1 minute
- 2Connect1 minute
- 3Plan6–10 minutes
- 4Pitch1 minute per group
- 5Close1 minute
- Pose the problem1 minute“Our cafeteria throws away about 40 pounds of food a day. Using what we learned today, how could we cut that?”(Use a real number if you have one, or have students estimate.)
- Connect1 minute“Which idea from today’s lesson helps here?”
- Plan6–10 minutesGroups write a fix in three parts: the problem, the concept they used and their proposal.
- Pitch1 minute per groupGroups share. The class asks one question each.
- Close1 minute“What did you have to understand about today’s concept to make that work?”
See it in action
Use measuring skills to plan a better layout for the classroom library.
Use ratios to plan a fair schedule for the school’s one gym.
Use persuasive writing techniques to draft a letter to the town about a crosswalk.
Watch out for
- Problems too big (“end hunger”): keep it local and small.
- Fixes that skip the concept: require groups to name the idea they used.
- Time creep: run a visible timer.
Level up
- Send the best fix to someone who can act on it.
- Groups estimate the cost or impact of their fix.
Make it work for everyone
- Multilingual learners: allow a labeled drawing of the solution.
- IEP and 504 supports: give a three-box planning frame (Problem / Concept / Fix).
- Early finishers: predict one way their fix could fail.
Tech option
Groups draft an email to a real person (a principal, a town office) in a shared doc.
Resources
Pairs well with
Reflect
Did students use the concept accurately, or did the problem distract from it?
Evidence
ModerateHerrington, J., & Oliver, R. (2000). An instructional design framework for authentic learning environments. Educational Technology Research and Development, 48(3), 23–48. Describes how realistic tasks help students build knowledge they can use outside school.
Find the research: Herrington (2000)
