Lesson Shuffle: Shuffle, Pick, Grow
Assessment & RetrievalCard Y12

Seeds of Insight

Ask the real experts

3 min, once a weekNo prepPractice-based

The move

Once a week, ask students what helped them learn and what got in the way, change one thing, and tell them you did.

See how it works

Askhelped? got inthe way?ReadLook for patternsChange 1 thingmost common askTell them“You said… so I…”Weekly

At a glance

Time in class
3 minutes, once a week
Prep
None
Materials
Slips of paper, or a two-question form
Grouping
Individual, anonymous
Use it when
End of class, once a week

Why it works

Students see your teaching from the other side of the desk. In a large national study, students’ survey ratings of their teachers predicted which classrooms made bigger learning gains. And telling students what you changed shows their voice matters, which makes the next round more honest.

Step by step

In class: about 3 min

  1. 1Hand out slips20 seconds
  2. 2Two questions2 minutes
  3. 5Close the loop30 seconds

Before class: Read

  1. Hand out slips20 secondsNo names.
  2. Two questions2 minutes“What helped you learn today? What got in the way? Be honest. No names.”
  3. ReadAfter class, 5 minutesSort into piles. Look for patterns, not single comments.
  4. Change one thingNext classPick the most common, doable request.
  5. Close the loop30 seconds“Several of you said the directions were too fast. So today they’re on the board too. Thank you.”

See it in action

Use smiley faces plus one word: “What helped? What was hard?”

Watch out for

Level up

Make it work for everyone

Tech option

A two-question anonymous form; it tallies answers for you.

Resources

Reflect

What did students say that surprised you?

Evidence

Practice-based

Kane, T. J., & Staiger, D. O. (2012). Gathering Feedback for Teaching: Combining High-Quality Observations with Student Surveys and Achievement Gains. Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, Measures of Effective Teaching (MET) Project. Student survey ratings predicted teachers’ achievement gains. That study used formal surveys; weekly feedback slips are a classroom-scale version.

Find the research: Kane (2012)