Lesson Shuffle: Shuffle, Pick, Grow
Classroom Systems & EquityCard R5

Hidden Hero

Spot the unsung hero

About 1 minNo prepModerate

The move

Find a student you rarely recognize and give them one sincere compliment that names something specific they did.

See how it works

Praise the person“You’re so smart.” Feels nice, teaches nothing.
Name the action“You checked every step twice.” Tells them what to keep doing.

At a glance

Time in class
About 1 minute
Prep
None
Materials
Class roster for tracking
Grouping
One student at a time
Use it when
Any day; aim for every class period

Why it works

Some students go weeks without hearing anything specific about their work. Recognition that names an action (“You checked every step twice”) tells students what to keep doing and builds the relationship. Praise aimed at the person (“You’re so smart”) is far less useful, so the key is naming what they did.

Step by step

In class: about 15 seconds

  1. 3Name the action10 seconds
  2. 5Log it5 seconds

Before class: Scan your roster

  1. Scan your roster30 seconds, before classPut a dot by students you haven’t recognized lately. Pick one.
  2. Watch for a momentDuring classEffort, a good question, helping someone, a strategy, improvement.
  3. Name the action10 seconds“Jordan, you went back and fixed your units without being asked. That’s exactly what scientists do.”
  4. Keep it low-keyQuietly at their desk works for most students, especially older ones.
  5. Log it5 secondsCheck the name off so you rotate through everyone.

See it in action

“You sounded out that whole word by yourself. I heard every sound.”

Watch out for

Level up

Make it work for everyone

Tech option

A checklist column in your gradebook or roster spreadsheet.

Resources

Reflect

Whose names are still unchecked after two weeks?

Evidence

Moderate

Hattie, J., & Timperley, H. (2007). The power of feedback. Review of Educational Research, 77(1), 81–112. Feedback about the task and the process is effective; praise aimed at the person is the least effective kind.

Simonsen, B., Fairbanks, S., Briesch, A., Myers, D., & Sugai, G. (2008). Evidence-based practices in classroom management. Education and Treatment of Children, 31(3), 351–380. Lists specific praise among well-supported practices.

Find the research: Hattie (2007) · Simonsen (2008)